Are you sending some
alternative ("ethical") gifts this year? I was disturbed to discover that an education charity is
claiming that 'give-a-goat'-type gifts "are degrading for developing countries". The Director of
Worldwrite suggests that "we should ditch the ethical items in our shopping trolleys. If we want to help our peers, we need to think big and hand over the money", and this month the charity is releasing two films that claim many NGO campaigns are simply about making people feel good and not about helping people. However, the manager of
Oxfam Unwrapped says that "What might feel like a fun thing to do at Christmas has
an impact the whole year round.... We work with communities who, at the beginning of each year, tell us what they need and want".
What do you think? I remembered an article
Getting your goat, from a couple of years ago that
follows up one such give-a-goat project and reports the positive impact on the community concerned.